When I was in high school I struggled with your usual teenage problems. I felt foreign in my own skin, completely alone, and useless. I also worked myself into a nice little eating disorder too- which was pretty ugly and did not help my teenage angst at all. It wasn’t like I had a horrible life or anything, I was just a depressed girl with no one to talk to and terribly low self-esteem.
Anyway, as my eating disorder spiraled out of control (like they always do) my poor mother did her best to try and help me. I refused and refused for the longest time, I loved being at my low weight and had found comfort in the isolated life that eating disorders encourage you to create.
After an especially scary episode, however, I finally decided to take my mom’s advice (mainly because I couldn’t take the turmoil that was being caused by me at home any more) and went to see a doctor. My doctor was really nice, she was Scottish and really pretty and skinny so of course I liked her. I was also under the impression, due to several comments she made during our first visit, that she struggled with an eating disorder at one time or another as well. Anyway, after some blood tests and all that I was told that if I didn’t improve my nutrition I was going to end up in the emergency room and that I should probably seek treatment. So I did, and along with treatment guess what else I got? Anti-depressants.
********************************************************************************
*Disclaimer* Antidepressants can really help some people, they could perhaps even save someone’s life. This is a telling of MY experience with those types of drugs, however, which was horrible, and I personally believe that along with having the potential to do good, anti-depressants can also have the complete opposite effect on some people. I am in no way saying that no one should take them, my point with this post is that you should always listen to your body, and don’t assume that anti-depressants are your only option. Please don’t post an assload of comments about how great they worked for you and I don’t know anything/ I’m an asshole for saying they’re bad/You hate me because I am badmouthing prozac/etc. This is my telling of my reaction.
********************************************************************************
Anyway, off I went to treatment, a semester off school and a full time job of talking about my feelings and my relationship with food, blah blah blah. I completed treatment, became healed of my eating disorder (well, not really, but I could at least once again function in society), and went back to complete my final year in high school. One thing that I had to hang onto, along with the mental tools I gained from my stay in the hospital, were those pesky pills that I never liked taking in the first place.
The first drug I was prescribed is, I believe, what really caused me to crack. I was messed up before, but after my visit with the Scottish doctor and right before I entered treatment (a span of about 2 weeks), I pretty much went bananas. I went from counting calories and over exercising (anorexia) to eating 4,000- 5,000 calories a day (sometimes in one or two sittings) and throwing up after each ‘meal’ (bulimia) almost overnight. I felt like I was going to jump out of my skin, and even felt the need to scratch and scratch myself- one time causing myself to bleed. I felt like a zombie, hated everyone, and remember laying on the floor numb telling my father that I just hated existing. After taking this medication for a few weeks, and then being in treatment for a few weeks, I talked to a different doctor and told him I did not like taking anti-depressants because of how they made me feel. He switched me to a different drug. Time went by, and like I said, I completed treatment and went back to school.
I continued taking my prescribed medication for another year, yet still struggled with horrible ‘black moods,’ feeling as though nothing could fix me, and just wanting to cease to exist- a numbness and feeling of hopelessness that I can’t even begin to describe accurately. I felt like I was just wrong! Even though I was on this pill that was supposed to keep me from getting in my horrible states, it seemed as though they were worse now than they were before I was taking anything! I continued to live this way, okay for a few weeks or maybe a month, then would be hit with a feeling of despair so deep I’m amazed I never tried to kill myself (the only thing that kept me from attempting this is the thought of how much it would hurt my mother).
So I began college, still occassionally struggling with ‘food issues’ (i.e. making myself puke) and began to despise taking my medicine. I would quit taking it (which is a BAD idea) and would feel even worse, but I knew that I was not myself when I was on it either. So I would go crazy if I stopped taking it, and would go crazy when I did take it. I would ask my doctors (three different doctors who I had been seeing since high school) to help me ween myself off (which is what you’re supposed to do when you quit) and they would just switch me to a different pill, which I would then not take because I was pissed. I would argue with my doctors about whether or not I even needed it, telling them that I was 16 when I started taking it, surely I was different now and maybe no longer needed it. Maybe my depression was a result of outside factors, not a chemical imbalance. Their answer to this was: a diabetic can’t just not take insulin anymore- this is something you will have to take the rest of your life.
What a horrible thing to tell a young, thoughtful girl who just happened to have a hard time during her teenage years!! What I heard when they told me this was: there is something wrong with you that cannot be fixed, it can only be treated. The phrase ’situational depression’ was not in their vocabulary, so I finally bit the bullet and threw out all my pills and quit cold turkey. I do not recommend this, because when you quit abruptly like that it makes your ‘levels’ go totally wacky- leaving you temporarily bat-shit crazy, even if you weren’t that bad to begin with. But I did it anyway because I figured anything would be better than constantly not feeling like myself and suffering from my ‘black moods.’ Luckily, thanks to smoking pot (I believe- because it got my mind off the bad thoughts I was having as a result of quitting my medicine instead of weening myself off) I managed to survive the following few weeks.
To this day (4 years later) I have not suffered any ‘black moods,’ have not wanted to kill myself, have not had any urges to return to my old eating disorder habits, and have managed to deal with life’s obstacles. Sometimes I still get in a bad mood, and feel like I have the weight of the world on my shoulders- but I can still go about my day and don’t feel paralyzed by sadness.
********************************************************************************
I think there are a lot of cases where anti-depressants can be very helpful to people. But I firmly believe that you cannot just put someone on a pill and forget about them, it’s important to work through whatever is making you depressed, everyone needs coping skills. And if you are taking medicine and don’t feel like yourself after giving your body a few weeks to adjust, then something is wrong. You need to establish a working relationship with your doctor and they should listen to you, not brush you off simply because you’re young or you don’t have a medical degree. If you are taking something and feel weird or feel like something isn’t right or feel like it just isn’t helping you, then you should really talk to someone and perhaps plan a different path for yourself (with the help of a professional of course- don’t do what I did).
Anyway, this is my story of eating disorders, teenage turnmoil, anti-depressants, and doctor’s who maybe need to work on listening to their patients. During my experience I took varying levels of Paxil, Prozac, Lexapro, Cymbalta, Xanax (which isn’t an anti-depressant), and Fluoxetine (which I was told by my doctor is different than Prozac, but later found out it is just generic Prozac); I was not prescribed Wellbutrin because it can cause people to lose weight, and because of my eating disorder the doctors didn’t want to start anything.






I had similar experiences with prozac. Whatever it does, my brain chemistry already does enough of. My treatment was for depression, although when I ended up on the psycho ward, they said I just needed marriage counseling. They were wrong. A divorce from #1and subsequent widowhood from #2 seems to have done the trick. I seem to do best when single.
Your main point, that many doctors want to hand you a pill and say, “take this for six weeks and see if you feel better, ” is one reason “health care” and pharmaceuticals are so expensive and often ineffective. I think women in particular are seen as hypochondriacs, or as whiners. Give her enough medication that she can’t think, and she’ll go away.
Wiht all the other tests that they have for all these varous kinds of illnesses, why can’t they test for brain chemistry imbalances? Those are the only kinds of depression that need constant treatment. I do know people who only function when they take antidepressants, so the pills are not the problem. It’s the attitude that “mother’s little helper” will take care of everything.
The last time I went to a doctor, he actually asked me what I had, and what I wanted for it. I had to wonder why I was paying him. This is why I am not too upset about not having health insurance.
By: Charlotte Babb on February 1, 2008
at 3:38 am
All of us have different DNA and different metabolisms. Some herbs and vitamins work better than others. The first thing that is needed is proper nutrition and a good physical exam. As the director of Novus Medical Detox, I often see patients who are on alcohol or opioids, central nervous system depressants, also taking antidepressants. When they detox they find they don’t need the antidepressants.
This is good news because a Swedish study showed that 52% of the 2006 suicides by women on antidepressants. Since antidepressants work no better than placebos and are less effective than exercise in dealing with depression.
There is a prescription drug epidemic and these are leaders in the list of terrible abuses.
Steve Hayes
http://novusdetox.com
By: steve hayes on March 3, 2008
at 1:08 am
i know exactly how you feel.
being put on a cocktail of medication.
it was interesting to read about ur experience.
we all have different experiences.
i know some people it has helped and some it hasnt.
thanks for sharing.
By: awry on September 29, 2008
at 6:38 am